Why Fewer People Are Challenging Bad Patents
The filing of Inter Partes Review (IPR) petitions at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has slumped dramatically, and the decline threatens a key safeguard against low‑quality software patents that can choke innovation and free expression online.
Sharp Drop in IPR Petitions: The Numbers
In the third quarter of 2026 (July‑September) only 97 IPR petitions were filed, a stark contrast to the 327 petitions37 petitions, while December 2024— the last full month before the current USPTO leadership reshaped PTAB procedures—recorded 129 petitions. These figures illustrate a collapse that cannot be explained by an improvement in patent quality.
The data alone signals a systemic problem: a 70%‑plus reduction in filings within a year, and a 71% drop from the pre‑leadership‑change baseline. When the avenue for inexpensive, administrative challenges dries up, litigants are forced into costly district‑court battles, or they simply abandon the fight.
USPTO Leadership’s Procedural Shift
Recent USPTO leadership has begun to “refuse to consider good challenges to patents,” according to industry observers, and this stance is unrelated to the substantive merits of the patents themselves. By altering the internal standards that PTAB uses to evaluate petitions, the Board has become “unreliable” in the eyes of potential challengers, prompting many to forego filing altogether.
This procedural drift undermines the original congressional intent behind IPRs. Congress created the IPR process precisely because the Patent Office “makes mistakes,” offering a faster, less expensive alternative to “extraordinarily expensive” district‑court litigation. When the Board’s gatekeeping function erodes, the statutory balance Congress struck is effectively broken.
Why Bad Patents Threaten Digital Free Speech
Software and internet patents often claim rights over fundamental online activities—sending email, serving ads, publishing web pages—tools that underpin modern expression. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) has long argued that “bad patents affect everyone who cares about the freedom to write new code and make new technology.” When such patents remain unchallenged, they become “powerful weapons” that can be wielded to suppress innovation and silence dissent.
Beyond the commercial impact, the civil‑liberties dimension is stark: a patent that monopolizes a basic communication method can be used to block speech, force licensing fees, or intimidate developers. The erosion of IPR filings therefore translates directly into a weakening of the legal infrastructure that protects digital free speech.
What This Actually Means For You
- Expect higher litigation costs if you or your company are sued over a software patent, because the cheap administrative route is effectively unavailable.
- Recognize that the decline in IPR filings is not a sign of better patents; it reflects a strategic retreat by challengers facing an unreliable PTAB.
- Understand that unchecked patents can limit the tools you rely on for everyday online communication, from email to web publishing.
- Realize that advocacy groups like EFF view robust IPR activity as essential to preserving digital free speech, so a drop in filings weakens that protective coalition.
- Anticipate that future legislative or judicial interventions may be required to restore the balance Congress intended for the patent system.
Immediate Action Steps
If you are a developer or a small business owner, begin documenting any patent threats early and explore alternative dispute‑resolution mechanisms while the PTAB remains unreliable. Engage with industry coalitions or civil‑rights groups that monitor patent abuse, as collective pressure can sometimes prompt the USPTO to reconsider its procedural stance.
Simultaneously, conduct a patent‑freedom‑to‑operate (FTO) analysis for your core technologies. Even without an IPR, a thorough FTO can reveal vulnerable claims and guide you toward design‑around strategies that reduce exposure to costly lawsuits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did IPR filings drop so sharply after 2024?
The drop coincides with a change in USPTO leadership that began “reshaping how the Board handles patent challenges,” making the process appear unreliable and discouraging potential challengers.
Can I still challenge a bad software patent without filing an IPR?
Yes, but the alternative is district‑court litigation, which the source describes as “extraordinarily expensive” compared to the administrative IPR route.
How does the decline in IPR petitions affect free expression online?
Bad patents that claim basic online tools can remain in force, and the source notes that this “affects everyone who cares about the freedom to write new code and make new technology,” thereby threatening digital free speech.
What Do You Think?
Given the USPTO’s current trajectory, should Congress intervene to restore a reliable administrative avenue for patent challenges, or is the market best left to self‑regulate?