Panel from 'Surveillance Isn\'t Safety' comic depicting a protest against a license‑plate reader camera on a city street.

Surveillance Isn't Safety: A Comic About Organizing Against Flock and Other Foes

Mass surveillance through automated license‑plate readers (ALPRs) is no longer an abstract policy debate; it is a lived reality for residents of dozens of U.S. cities, and a new free comic titled “Surveillance Isn’t Safety” brings that conflict into stark focus. By dramatizing the Cleveland fight against Flock Safety, the comic exposes how corporate narratives, legal loopholes, and community organizing intersect in ways that directly affect civil liberties. Readers who value transparent governance and personal freedom need to understand the mechanisms at play before they become entrenched in law.

The Comic as a Lens on ALPR Opposition

The comic, created by cartoonist Bryn Adams and released in partnership with the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) and Crucial Comix, translates complex activism into a narrative that is both accessible and emotionally resonant. Its release “today” as a free PDF underscores a strategic choice to lower barriers to information, mirroring the grassroots aim of democratizing the debate over surveillance technology. By following a personal journey, the story illustrates how ordinary residents evolve from passive observers to organized protestors.

Beyond storytelling, the comic serves as a documentation of real‑world tactics: community meetings, petition drives, and legal challenges that have already led to “cancelled contracts” with vendors like Flock. This visual record validates the movement’s claims that ALPRs are not merely benign tools but instruments that can produce “mistakes, abuse, racism, and targeting of dissenters, migrants, and abortion seekers.” The medium amplifies the urgency, making the stakes palpable for readers who might otherwise dismiss policy papers as distant.

Corporate Narrative vs Grassroots Reality

Flock Safety founder Garrett Langley attempted to delegitimize opposition at the International Association of Chiefs of Police conference by labeling activists as “Russian bots” and “inorganic.” He argued that the repetition of protest slogans proved external manipulation, a claim that conflates coordinated messaging with foreign interference. This rhetorical tactic seeks to shift focus from the substantive harms of ALPR deployment to an alleged threat of disinformation.

In contrast, the comic highlights that shared slogans are a hallmark of social movements, not evidence of manipulation. The alignment of language across cities reflects a collective response to common grievances, such as documented cases of racial profiling and privacy violations. By exposing Langley’s misdirection, the narrative equips readers with a framework to critically assess corporate PR strategies that aim to silence dissent.

Legal and Policy Implications of Cancelled Contracts

The tangible outcome of the Cleveland campaign—cancellation of the city’s contract with Flock—demonstrates that organized pressure can translate into enforceable policy change. While the source does not enumerate specific statutes, the cancellation signals a breach of the implicit social contract that permits municipal procurement of surveillance tools without robust public oversight. It also raises questions about the enforceability of existing privacy protections under state and federal law.

These developments suggest a shifting legal landscape where municipalities may be compelled to conduct impact assessments, public hearings, or adopt moratoria on ALPR use. The comic’s depiction of this process underscores that legal victories are rarely instantaneous; they require sustained advocacy, strategic litigation, and media engagement. For readers, the precedent set in Cleveland could serve as a template for challenging similar contracts elsewhere.

What This Actually Means For You

  1. Community activism can halt or reverse municipal surveillance contracts, as evidenced by Cleveland’s cancelled agreement with Flock.
  2. Corporate claims of “inorganic” protest are a common deflection; coordinated slogans often indicate a unified movement, not foreign interference.
  3. Legal avenues—public hearings, impact assessments, and potential litigation—are viable tools for citizens to demand transparency.
  4. Free resources like the “Surveillance Isn’t Safety” comic provide a concise roadmap for understanding and joining the fight against ALPRs.
  5. Continued vigilance is required because the same technology is being adopted by other vendors such as Axon, expanding the surveillance footprint.

Immediate Action Steps

Start by downloading the free PDF of the comic and sharing it within local civic groups; its visual format makes the issue easy to discuss at town halls or neighborhood meetings. Next, request your city council’s records on any existing contracts with ALPR vendors and demand a public forum to evaluate their impact on privacy and equity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main argument of the “Surveillance Isn’t Safety” comic?

The comic argues that mass surveillance via ALPRs causes real harms—mistakes, racial bias, and targeting of vulnerable groups—and that community activism can successfully challenge and cancel such contracts.

How did Flock Safety’s founder respond to anti‑surveillance protests?

Garrett Langley accused activists of being driven by “Russian bots” and labeled their efforts “inorganic” at an International Association of Chiefs of Police conference, using the claim to undermine the legitimacy of the movement.

Are there any documented successes against ALPR vendors?

Yes; the Cleveland case resulted in a cancelled contract with Flock, demonstrating that organized local opposition can produce concrete policy reversals.

What Do You Think?

Given the clear evidence that coordinated community action can dismantle surveillance contracts, should more municipalities proactively audit their ALPR deployments before expanding them?

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.